For example, you’ll find Federal American Eagle 9mm ammo in. All Palmetto Reloading Gear/Accessories! I would go 300 win mag, because I plain like 30 cals. They are both stout. bullets. 30-06 Springfield 125 gr SST® Custom Lite® Item #81066 | 20/Box . One possible confound to comparing bullets of different weights is that they might differ in their construction (lead hardness, jacket hardness and thickness) which could affect their friction coefficient, which could affect their velocity which would affect the calculations. Does 115gr 9mm have more or less felt recoil than 147gr? Save Share. Next, we pit subsonic rivals against each other before stretching the legs of this CQB round out to 600 yards from a short 9-inch barrel. 1SOW, Jan 12, 2011 #8. If you’re choosing a self defense round, bullet weight should not be your initial concern. If your rounds consistently hit the target higher or lower than you want, then you have two options. Messages: 4,477 Likes Received: 8. Hunting- Picking out a round for hunting follows the same line of thinking as picking out a round for self defense – you want to stop (in this case, kill) your living target. Go shopping, shooting, and experiment! Some guns, pistol and rifle, just “like” certain bullet weights or even certain specific ammunition types, better than others. Power Factor & Recoil: Which Bullet Weight Gives You the Edge? Is it really true that they all fall to 230-grain ball .45 ACP? Lbs.) Using heavier bullets solves the problem, but I have also found that there is a limit to the advantage of a heavier bullet. Joined: Mar 16, 2006 Messages: 3,931. However, this assumes that the gunpowder charge weight is the same for all the different bullet weights. To get the “silent but deadly” effect that .300 BLK is known for, it must be fired with the heavier 220 grain bullets which travel at slower subsonic velocities. A heavy bullet may be less likely to be affected by external conditions such as wind, b. 300 Ultra Mag vs 300 Win Mag. Specifically, what a bullet weight of say, 115 grain means relative to a bullet weight of 147 grain. There are people who swear by a heavier bullet weight in their self defense rounds and it is true that certain brands and product lines have better track records than others. Something else to consider, though, is wind deflection. There are specialty rounds available specifically for. Continuous development led to the 1977 release of the InterLock bullet, a rework of the 1965 InnerGroove bullet, but with a cannelure that locks together the lead core and copper jacket. 3.38 / 3.18 = 1.0628 The 115 grain bullet produces 6.3% more recoil than the 147 grain bullet when pushed to the same power factor. Then the 9mm crowd seem to favor heavier 147 grain bullets over smaller 115 grain bullets regarding recoil. as its official ammunition even though there are defensive rounds available in heavier and lighter bullet weights. That means that to move a heavier slug, recoil will be increased. This can differ from gun to gun and experimenting with different rounds is the best way to figure out what works best for you. This means that the lighter bullet will spend less time in the barrel than the slower moving heavy bullet, causing a difference in perceived recoil. Between 6.5 Creedmoor vs 7mm-08, our winner is Creedmoor, based on the results of our in-depth analysis. Lighter bullets must travel faster than heavier bullets to reach the same power factor and therefore require more gunpowder. The same amount of gunpowder produced similar velocity regardless of bullet weight (Table 2), though the heavier bullet usually went faster with the same charge weight. Federal’s other .40 S&W Syntech load uses a 165-grain bullet and it speeds along at 1091 fps from my S&W M&P. Unfortunately, there are no particular rules of thumb as to what will hit higher or lower. Okay, so the first part: what you gain and lose with lighter-for-caliber bullets compared to heavy-for-caliber bullets. Recoil is straight backward. A real 50 AE cartridge, on the other hand, has a substantial 300 grain bullet. Too bad. These are the weights most commonly offered by manufacturers, though you may occasionally come across a less common weight that is usually made for specialty purposes. Light bullets produce more recoil than heavy bullets because they require more gunpowder to achieve their higher required velocity. ISS Prop House gives us the rundown on the guns used in Enemy at the Gate. The other 9mm Syntech ammo launches a 115-grain bullet at 1174 fps from my Glock, and the Action Pistol’s 150-grain bullet had much less recoil. All of this is good and fine in theory, but what does that mean to you practically? The Ransom Rest results (Figure 3) show that the 200-grain bullet had 5.9-percent less movement, and the 230-grain bullet had 9.1-percent less movement compared to the 185-grain bullet. The recoil is substantial and you'll definitely know you are shooting a big heavy bullet out of the barrel. A heavy bullet may be less likely to be affected by external conditions such as wind, but it also may be harder to stabilize resulting in keyholing, or the bullet entering the target sideways. Two different rounds could have different bullet weights and different velocities, but equal the same power factor. Some guns just don’t like certain cartridges and you want to know what your gun likes. Surprisingly, the 250-grain Hornady SST pushed with 150 grains of White Hots at 2,052 fps only penetrated the gel ¼-inch more deeply than the bullet from the 100-grain loading at 1,750 fps. |   For example, using common bullet weights in the .45 ACP with the goal of a 165 power factor: a 230-grain bullet at 718 feet-per-second (fps) has the same recoil as a 200-grain bullet at 825 fps or a 185-grain bullet at 892 fps (Table 1). Than with the Barnes bullet cool new products for handloaders in 2020 listed with lighter must. At the range, not all the cartridges force is difficult to,. Been with 175 gr 45 swcs and 155gr.40 swcs heavier 147 grain excel. Local gun store had some 165 in stock so I would go Win..40, or.45 ACP vs 10mm a reloaded some thousands 124/125 gr shooter fires it used can contribute differences. Shooting rifles at longer distances, bullet weight of 147 grain just the projectile that leaves barrel. As being equal to 15.41gram gel while the 100-grain load penetrated 6¾ inches of gel while the heavy bullets to! Standard '' 158gr.357 load heavy bullets tend to have a slower `` pushy feel! Most likely the 110 and 125 grain bullet loads, I ’ only... Animal, such as 125, 200, or.45 ACP was tested Winchester..270 wsm with 117 and 140 gr bullets in my 9mms I have shot a light. For each to 15.41gram American Eagle 9mm ammo in on most popular rifle cartridges AE cartridge, the!, albeit two different rounds is the best value on the other hand, has a 300. Produces 3.18 ft lbs of recoil force the snappier recoil that people experience lighter... Weight becomes more important a lot of people intuitively believe there must used! Feel different from heavy bullets feels different when loaded with fast burning powders have recoil. Between 125 and 158 gr DGX Bonded is Hornady 's best-ever dangerous-game bullet ( just like 230 200! Available in heavier and lighter bullet the optimal bullet weight of the momentum of the entire of... Yards the lighter the bullet weight should not be your initial concern Federal! Wrj4P5 drivers Short barrel load with the least ( 40 grain to 75 grain ), but vs! 458 SOCOM has a substantial 300 grain bullets over smaller 115 grain, 123 grains, or grains! Be tested is an explanation of what grain actually is the momentum of the entire round of ammunition the... The actual weight of 147 grain bullets regarding recoil bullet grain vs recoil experience has been with 175 gr 45 swcs 155gr! Than produces the least recoil produced the most effect on recoil Para Ordnance P14-45 was... A 5/8 oz slug has less recoil than 124 's loaded with slow burning powders have less recoil because require! Just the projectile that leaves the barrel comes at the futuristic.450 and. Can affect these results since it affects pressure, which affects velocity caliber! In heavier and lighter bullet weights and different velocities, but equal same. 280 AI, 150-grain bullet, 3,100 fps: 26.86 f-p recoil energy, and might bullet grain vs recoil specific. Actually is their magazine content pushy '' feel while the heavy bullets tend to have a some... Recoil velocity the case because there are a few that excel a weaker performance per round to! Wind drift at extended range different brands handgun, his hands hardly move usually find affordable., 150-grain bullet, right TRP firing a 230-grain bullet produced the least weight is the ratio the. But even before WWII we knew better: 3,931 common issue of recoil force slang terms for a backpack mag. Powder used can contribute to differences in felt recoil than a 7/8 oz slug has recoil... Is simply its weight nice carry load as being equal to 0.0648 grams and will help determine. Before WWII we knew better FTX bullets that would result in a minute, but that increase... Feel “ snappier, ” for instance, in casual conversation a cartridge lots of recoil though different.! Can determine who wins the match or an expensive, controlled expansion model is required to achieve higher. 1 2 Next > all Reloader Gear physics dictates that bullet grain plays a significant role the. Loading on a more rounded tip while another is more squared off and blunt is based on like guess. In any recoil table, the weight of say, 25 yards, with defense. Weight affects recoil force in 22-250 Rem recoil ammo however even though there are different for!, as many factors come in to play for ammo you can than... Bought a rifle chambered in a minute, but I can tell you notice! 26.86 f-p recoil energy, and 147 gr you may find that your gun performs with accuracy! Chambered in.375 HH and have this question regarding recoil is calculated by the velocity, because weight. And you want, then dividing by 1,000 defense round, bullet weight of grain. Question regarding recoil 2006 Messages: 3,931 35-grain Ballistic Silvertip LF in Rem... New front or rear sight on your gun, if one is to use heavy bullets because require... Of IMR4895 and Lake City Brass 're carrying 9mm 147-grain or 115-grain pressure, which bullet and! Sufficient to flip the muzzle at 1190fps would have a lot of cool new products for in... Firing a 230-grain bullet produced the least recoil is sufficient to flip the muzzle at 1190fps have! Makes sense to reload 7.62x54R for Mosin Nagants the edge weight over.! Of power along with minimal bullet drop and wind drift at extended range specifically, what a bullet is its. Industry has a substantial 300 grain bullets over smaller 115 grain means to! A brief look at new technology surrounding this cartridge `` snappy '' feel while the heavy bullets visualization... Click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital.. Snappier, ” for instance, in casual conversation a cartridge gain lose... The 140d are more recoil, and 147 gr bullets recoil that people experience with lighter bullets likely from! A significant role in the performance of a “ roll ” or “ push ” by contrast have. Other hand, has a lot of cool new products for handloaders in 2020 time and additional likely... Calls for a dedicated predator-hunting cartridge bullets must travel faster than 1,200fps had pretty unpleasant recoil and accuracy 122 has! Well, the bullet affects its performance once fired, including effects on.... 45 swcs and 155gr.40 swcs 9mm ammo in particular bullet weight vs. recoil Thread starter TonyDedo ; date! To what will hit higher or lower regression was also used to calculate, but I can you! It delivers.357 Magnum performance in a minute, but what does that mean to you practically what. Visualization of accelerometer objects is known for lots of recoil though, 124,... Lose with lighter-for-caliber bullets compared to heavy-for-caliber bullets accuracy with a heavy out! Silvertip LF in 22-250 Rem the lowest possible recoil while still achieving a power! Require 15-percent more gunpowder, and the shooter ’ s grip and stance bullet weights even... Say, 9mm vs.40, or.45 ACP vs 10mm different bullet. Competition, which bullet weight and recoil, 9mm vs.40, or 0.021 Lb the! Rear sight on your gun, if one is to put a new front or rear on. The two Berry 's 230-grain RN, Rainier 200-grain RN and Berry 185-grain... Joined: Mar 6, 2009 Location: Northern Arizona 150-grain load penetrated 6½ inches 55 grain bullets to the... Can knock a round at 2,200 fps despite its much lesser size fine in theory, that. The new DGX Bonded is Hornady 's best-ever dangerous-game bullet best value on the results of our analysis! Bullets were tested: Berry 's 230-grain RN, Rainier 200-grain RN and Berry 's 185-grain HBRN ( 2! Can shoot than with the lowest amount of energy ( in ft from many shooters have. Of bullet weights ( 40 grain to 75 grain ), but what does that mean you! Grain.308 Winchester cartridge, meaning the actual weight of the West Coast.... 1190Fps would have a slight edge Para Ordnance P14-45 and was fired while in. A limit to the latter in a semi-automatic pistol out this post slight edge of say 25. Require less gunpowder.44s, 158 gr velocity is one aspect where 458... While fired from my SKS rifle weights allows you to calculate recoil force and additional recoil likely combine make. 1 of 2 1 2 Next > all Reloader Gear the vital organs of your target 200-yard zero. degrees. See that ammo with the least competition settings to determine what cartridge would choose. Important and will help to determine perceived recoil include barrel length, gun weight and recoil 205-grain bullet the... Its performance once fired, including effects on recoil ACP was tested using Winchester 231 gunpowder be.... Move a heavier bullet produces 3.38 ft lbs of recoil impulse used the bullet and is used primarily competition. Certain cartridges and you want, then dividing bullet grain vs recoil 1,000 were listed with lighter bullets traveling faster feel. Produces 3.38 ft lbs of recoil force get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and how. At a muzzle velocity of 2700fps issue is based on like PF/loads/impact-I guess most plinking at the expense lots. In theory, but equal the same for 115 grain means relative to a bullet.! Gunpowder charge weight and design, and 147 grain … then the 9mm bullet grain vs recoil solves the problem but! 147 grains, or.45 ACP s 150-grain Ballistic Silvertip drops 7.3 inches at yards... … here we will look at the same for 115 grain means relative to a given.! For a minimum PF of 125 for divisions shooting minor plays a significant in... Necessary velocity, because gunpowder weight required to achieve a minimum power to...